
Courtesy NBT Bank
by Kenneth J. Entenmann, CFA®
5/20/2025, 3:07:02 PM
For the bulk of this century, it has been said that America was exceptional. It had the world’s strongest military. It had the world’s largest and richest economy. It had the world’s reserve currency. It had the world’s largest, safest, and most liquid financial markets. Most of the world’s largest and most innovative companies were American. The United States was a juggernaut. American Exceptionalism!
Yet, somehow, in just a few months, there are rumblings of the end of American Exceptionalism. Prominent financiers speak of damage to the “American brand.” The “Magnificent Seven” tech sector received a wake-up call when the Chinese Deepseek AI model was announced, which showed that the path to AI dominance would be competitive. And finally, Moody’s became the last of the major bond rating agencies to downgrade the last U.S. Treasury bond rating from AAA to AA.
Is this the beginning of the end of American exceptionalism? To paraphrase Mark Twain, the report of the demise of American exceptionalism is an exaggeration.
Apparently, several prominent financiers believe that the American brand has been damaged. Perhaps. They say our “Friends and Allies” can no longer trust the U.S. regarding military and trade. Certainly, the method of the Trump Administration’s demands for increased NATO military spending can be questioned. But the fact remains that many of our NATO “friends” are still significantly below the NATO minimum spending requirements, and even those who have committed to increased spending will not get there for several years. Given our fiscal challenges, the U.S. simply cannot afford to fund all of NATO. If calling for the end of our allies’ defense-free-riding ways is damaging to the U.S. brand, then so be it. Similarly, the rollout of the Trump trade program has been chaotic and has created great uncertainty. Our friends and allies are upset. That is understandable. But it is also very clear that these friends and allies are not free traders. They deploy a myriad of tariffs and non-tariff barriers to trade, such as a digital service tax on the U.S. tech sector, which are blatantly unfair. If calling this out is damaging our “brand,” then so be it. Regardless of the perception of the brand, the U.S. economy will remain the largest and richest consumer market in the world. Every country in the world still wants and needs to do business here. That is why there are so many ongoing trade negotiations. The hope is they will end with a freer and fairer trade environment with our Western allies.