The Belmont Stakes, in which American Pharoah broke the spell of 37 years and won the Triple Crown, was such an historic and otherworldly event that it’s taken me a full two weeks to process it.
Speaking with a friend yesterday and others during the past 15 days, my experience is not uncommon. Apparently only those people who are clear-headed enough to hold jobs in which they must write on-demand for deadlines have had the wherewithal to pen reports and observations about the events that unfolded on June 6, 2015 at Belmont Park.
While I’m very close to being able to sit down and tell readers everything that took place that day–in my world, in my head–I’m not there yet.
But the topic about which I am ready to write–once again–is the marketing of horse racing. How not to do it, and yes, to whom and how it should be done.
I’m inspired to write this based on things that I witnessed on Belmont Stakes Day, in-person, and a totally-unscientific (yet revealing) marketing experiment that I conducted that day at Belmont Park.
Based on what I witnessed that day, two things were confirmed for me:
1) The attempt to market horse racing to young people (late teens, and 20-somethings) via electronic devices and video games is the same as trying to ride a horse, facing the tail.
Ass-backward, and just plain wrong.
2) Arrogance of youth and “progress” notwithstanding–just being at a race track does not make one a race fan, any more than a cat having kittens in an oven makes them, biscuits. It’s still necessary to teach them why they should be there–and that WHY is and always will be–The Horse…
Don’t waste any of your time or mine, accusing me of being a Luddite or an Old Broad who’s just not tuned into technology or trends.
I worked first on computers in 1980, in the fledgling Computer Graphics department of a major technological university. In 1984, I was one of the clerical-types forced to use a “brand new” Mac (with a mouse!) at that same university. (The engineers wanted to see how user-friendly was this new Mac-thing, so I was given a 300-page paper to enter.)
So I’ve worked on virtually every computer that’s evolved in 35 years, from a gigantic Lanier word processor, hooked up to a $5 million Prime computer that took an entire, frozen room to hold–to the teeny-ish BlackBerry that I use because I need a real QWERTY keyboard. And everything in-between.
But the last computer game that held my interest for more than three seconds was Pong, at those aforementioned university jobs.
The key reason why I don’t play computer games is the same reason why I don’t take pictures often with my phone: I’m more interested in living in the moment–in having actual, flesh-and-blood experiences and the memories that stay with me, than in allowing a tool to stand in-between me and the experience.
Why would I–or you, or anyone else–prefer to fiddle with a computer game about horse racing when the option exists to be at a real, live horse race and experience real horses in all their glory? Sure, I understand playing racing games if you can’t get to the track–or it’s the dead of winter–or myriad other reasons that may prevent in-person track visits.
But to be at a race track, within mere feet of God’s most magnificent creatures–and still be attached to your iPhone–and playing a racing video game!–is an addiction, folks. I hate to be the one to break this to you, but it’s true. If you can’t put down the phone and the racing game long enough to look UP and see an actual HORSE–you are addicted.
A friend who’s a racing analyst, former jockey and trainer tells the tale of speaking to a group of young people in a corporate suite at Saratoga. To his dismay, after he spoke, he saw the majority of those young people texting and playing computer games on their phones almost immediately.
Even computer games about horse racing—even as huge, 1,200-pound horses throbbed past them, not 20 feet away.
They could feel the floor beneath their feet rumble, and probably attributed it to an Adirondack earthquake.
Dismaying–yes. Astounding, as well. The problem as I see it is that, like many annoying 21st Century parents (and we all know parents like this), horse racing is more interested in being the “friend” of youths, rather than taking responsibility and leading the way. (More parents in 21st Century America are afraid of hurting their little darlings’ feelings, or making their kids angry with them–instead of sucking it up and saying “NO” when it’s necessary.)
Not dissimilarly, horse racing allows the computer companies that are run by 12-year-olds to tell us that they want digital–when the reality is that they’ll never–EVER–become lifelong race fans and bettors unless/until they meet a horse, face-to-face, eye-to-eye, heart-to-heart.
I believe that the most successful and happiest participants in fantasy horse racing games are not those who start there, but who end up in that realm because they started as horse lovers and race fans in the flesh.
So the conclusion to Part 1 of this article is that horse racing must take The Hard Route: don’t emulate the lazy parents who find it easier to stick their kids in front of the TV, than to engage them in one-on-one play. Horse racing’s authorities must think of ways to introduce young people to horses. Real, live horses.
We all know that this is true, because every single one of us who works in the sport (whatever our gig)–somewhere along the line was introduced to a horse. And probably at an early age, when surrendering wholeheartedly to love wasn’t prevented by cynicism.
It may be that horse racing organizations must start working with Pony Club–with 4H–with local breeding farms and civic organizations. Race tracks may have to hire someone for the marketing department who’s dedicated to creating a grassroots campaign. One club–one horse–one child. It may cost some money and energy to get the campaign rolling, bt I can guarantee that, if you create the space and the environment–those children will respond.
In 2000, I had the previously-mentioned hateful job of working at the Saratoga Borders store, as CRM. (Read that, PR Slave.) I had to conduct a Children’s Camp during the summer, and honestly I don’t remember any of it except one event:
I found a local woman who owned a Thoroughbred breeding farm, and asked her to come and speak to the kiddies. (At the end of our phone conversation, I slid it in: “Ummmmm…and…could you bring…a horse with you…?”)
😉
I asked New York Thoroughbred Breeders to get involved, as well.
The lady–whose name I wish I could remember, she was so wonderful–spoke to 32 children in the store, about horsies and how to treat them. How to meet them, feed carrots to them, and why we should be kind to horsies. (She really was awesome, I wish you ALL could have heard her.)
The children were held in rapt attention, but after the talk, they went (quietly) berserk, for the dear breeder had brought a Thoroughbred mare and her foal with her. Mommy and baby were in a trailer in the parking lot behind Borders, right in downtown Saratoga. Both sides of the trainer were opened: Children walked through–quietly, as they’d been instructed–they petted the horses’ noses–and when they emerged on the other side, NYTBreeders’ resresentatives gave them NYTB helium balloons that featured their logo. (Mare/foal)
Do you think that those 32 children took away a memory to last a lifetime? Do you think that, perhaps, 15 years later–25% of those kids now attend the races of their own volition?
I do. Having first ridden a horse at age four, I know the impression that experience made on me. I fell in love that day, so I know that at least one-quarter of those wide-eyed, respectful children who got to pat two horsies’ noses–fell in love that hot August day in a downtown Saratoga parking lot.
Introduce a child to a horse, and grow horse racing.
Depend on technology to do all the work for you–and watch the sport spiral downward.
Virtual reality never will replace the smell–the soft nickers and primal neighing–the touch–the musculature–the otherworldly eye–the snorting, pawing, powerhouse that we know as The Horse.
No hologram, video game or other piece of technology ever can replace the first moment of meeting a horse in the flesh. To continue to push the concept of growing the sport virtually instead of really is an exercise in both idiocy and short-sightedness.
End, Part 1
For Part 2, please read
Horse Racing and Youth: But Will You Love Me Tomorrow?